Skip to main content
Mythos

Philosophical Anarchist

A Philosophical Anarchist is a person who is skeptical about all claims to authority, holding that no one can obligate another to act simply by commanding it; the term describes a position in political philosophy, not a program of disorder.

The position is most associated with the philosopher Robert Paul Wolff, whose In Defense of Anarchism (1970) argues that our ability to reason makes us responsible for what we do and obliges us to think our actions through. On Wolff's account a responsible person acts autonomously, according to decisions reached through her own deliberation; she recognizes responsibilities to others but insists that she alone judges them. Because authority demands deference and autonomy forbids it, Wolff concludes the two are incompatible. It may be fine to do what someone else says, but never merely because they said it.

Scott Hershovitz introduces the idea in the chapter on authority in Nasty, Brutish, and Short: Adventures in Philosophy with My Kids (2022). Wolff, who taught at Harvard, Chicago, Columbia, and UMass, is not "the sort of anarchist who takes to the street seeking mischief and mayhem"; calling him a philosophical anarchist, Hershovitz writes, "is just a fancy way of saying that he's skeptical about all claims to authority."

The chapter weighs Wolff against the reasons people do accept authority. Joseph Raz's service conception holds that the point of authority is to serve its subjects by helping them act better than they would alone. Other reasons include coordination problems, such as everyone driving on the same side of the road or a team following one coach; experience and expertise; expediency, deferring now and seeking an explanation once the urgency passes; and formal authority, accepting that a role carries the decision.

It's a delicate balance. Sometimes you have to accept that someone else has the authority to make that decision, and sometimes we want our people to learn to make decisions. In the moment: accept, reflect and improve.

Contexts

🏷️#dictionary

MythOS is a product of Cooperating Citizens of One, Inc.

TermsPrivacyRefundsContact

© 2026 Cooperating Citizens of One, Inc. · MythOS since 2017 · Not affiliated with Anthropic.